Keystone Dentistry Reviews
4.9 out of 5 stars based on 252 reviews on Google.
Steve Greenberg · 5 out of 5 stars · 3 months ago
After years of what I would call miss-the-mark dentistry, I’ve found a home with Keystone Dentistry. Dr. Nick Kitcoff and his staff are so patient centric, welcoming, professional, knowledgeable and offered full transparency on everything that was happening or going to happen. No one tried to “up-sell” me on anything, which was something of a first for me. My crown procedure was effortless (for me) and the regular cleaning was similarly fantastic. The doctor uses technologies new to me, which make everything incredibly efficient. It’s all set up to be (nearly) one-stop “shopping.” That’s what I’ve been looking for all these years, and now I have it. Thank you, Keystone Dentistry!
Megan Patel · 5 out of 5 stars · 2 months ago
I can't say enough good things about Dr. Kitcoff and the entire team at Keystone Dentistry. From the very first phone call with Christy at the front desk, I felt like I was in good hands.
I chipped a tooth and needed a crown on a previous root canal, but I was only in the area for two weeks before leaving for vacation. Despite their busy schedule, they got me in for a consultation right away and were able to fit me in for both issues the week after. Not only that — they actually stayed after hours to make sure everything was completed before I left so I wouldn't be dealing with pain or complications while traveling. That kind of dedication is something I've never experienced at any other dental office.
Ashley was fantastic during my visit. She and Dr. K walked me through every step of the procedure, answered all of my questions, and genuinely checked in to make sure I was comfortable and doing okay. I spent an entire afternoon in their chair, and honestly, they made it as pleasant as a dental visit for tooth pain can possibly be.
I've been to more dentists than I can count from moving around between New Jersey, Florida, and now Indiana, and I have never felt this level of care and compassion from a dental team. Dr. K never tried to upsell me on unnecessary work. Instead, he focused on saving the teeth he could, protecting them from future damage, and putting together a prioritized treatment plan that he took the time to explain thoroughly. His honesty and perspective were so refreshing and most of all he listened to what I was comfortable with and tried to make it happen.
Because of this experience, I'm finally ready to tackle the dental work I've been putting off for years. Past experiences had made me genuinely afraid to go to the dentist, but Dr. Kitcoff and his team have completely changed that for me. I feel so lucky to have found this practice, and I truly cannot recommend them enough. If you're looking for a dentist who actually cares, this is the place.
Catherine Hardwick · 5 out of 5 stars · 6 months ago
Love Dr Nick and his team. They are always friendly and creative a warm environment. They are very thorough with my regular cleanings and helpful in guiding me through my invisiline treatment to correct dental movement decades after traditional braces as a teenager. Age 54
Patrick Rayman · 5 out of 5 stars · 3 months ago
Keystone dentistry is amazing. They made me feel comfortable and explained everything they were doing thoroughly. Great staff and service!
Barb Sheets · 5 out of 5 stars · 8 months ago
This is a special dental office. Kristie is so welcoming and friendly. Ashley, my hygienist, was thorough and gentle!
Dr. Kitcoff is so professional and up to date on options for dental work that I did not realize were available!
I am relatively new to Indianapolis… this practice is as good as my old practice in Cincinnati that I went to for years:)
Reviews provided by Google.
About Keystone Dentistry
Keystone Dentistry is a family dental practice located at 2828 East 96th Street in Indianapolis, near the intersection of 96th Street and Keystone Avenue, serving patients throughout Indianapolis, Carmel, and the surrounding communities. The practice offers a full range of implant based tooth replacement, including single tooth implants, multiple implant restorations, and full arch solutions such as All on 4, along with supporting procedures like bone grafting and sinus lift surgery when a patient needs extra bone support before an implant can be placed. Patients considering implants can expect a thorough evaluation, including imaging of the jaw, before any surgery is scheduled, and the office also provides sedation options for patients who feel anxious about treatment.
Beyond implants, Keystone Dentistry provides general and cosmetic dental care such as same day crowns, veneers, clear aligner orthodontics, teeth whitening, and routine preventive care, so patients can handle most of their dental needs in one office. The practice is led by two general dentists, and the team emphasizes clear, unhurried explanations of treatment options so patients understand their choices before moving forward with a procedure like a dental implant. The office has served Indianapolis area families for more than three decades and offers early morning appointment times and financing options for patients weighing the cost of implant treatment.
Meet the Doctors
Dr. Wayne Kinney, D.D.S. is a longtime dentist at Keystone Dentistry who earned his dental degree from Indiana University and has completed additional implant training through the Midwest and Misch Institutes and the American Academy of Implant Dentistry's Maxi Course. He has practiced in the Indianapolis area for decades and holds Master status with the Academy of General Dentistry. Dr. Nicholas Kitcoff, D.D.S. also practices at this location. He earned his dental degree from the University of Tennessee after completing undergraduate studies at Indiana University-Purdue University Indianapolis, and the practice's own website describes him providing general, cosmetic, and restorative dental care alongside Dr. Kinney at the 96th Street office.
